From backcountry ski tours to mountaineering in some of the most brutal weather on Earth, a 4-season tent is the last line of defense between you and the elements. Accordingly, these tents are much stronger than their 3-season counterparts with less mesh, more substantial canopies and rainflies, tougher pole structures, and a whole host of features designed for winter use. Below are our picks for the best 4-season tents of 2020. Given the range of possible uses, we’ve categorized the different models under mountaineering, basecamp, and treeline. For more background, see our 4-season tent comparison table and buying advice below the picks.
Packaged weight: 9 lbs. 10 oz.
Floor area: 40 sq. ft.
What we like: Tough build and great livability.
What we don’t: Heavy.
Choosing our favorite 4-season tent was no easy task, but Mountain Hardwear deftly balances it all with their time-tested Trango 2. This tent knows bad weather as well as any other, with a burly, double-wall design and fly that connects not only to the poles but also to the body of the tent for added security in high winds. With two doors and two vestibules you get great livability, and the generous 40 square foot footprint is significantly roomier than any other 2-person model here. In their most recent update, Mountain Hardwear shifted the vestibule pole location to under the fly and incorporated non-fire-retardant (read: non-toxic) materials.
Ultimately, the decision between the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 and a single-wall tent like the Black Diamond Eldorado below comes down to your winter camping style. Some feel that the extra pounds are worth the added features and space, while others want to get up and down the mountain with as little weight as possible in their pack. One upside of the Trango 2 is that it’s easy to divvy up with your climbing partner to split the weight (single-wall tents often are not). And if weight isn’t an issue—which might be the case if you have porters or are flying into an area—the Trango comes in 3- and 4-person models for even more basecamp luxury.
See the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2
Best Single-Wall Mountaineering Tent
Packaged weight: 5 lbs. 1 oz.
Floor area: 30.8 sq. ft.
What we like: Lightweight and compact.
What we don’t: Mediocre ventilation and internal pole structure.
The Black Diamond Eldorado is a classic. Despite numerous updates over the years, this single-wall, two-pole tent has withstood a whole lot of blustery winter nights and summit pushes. Most importantly, durability and build quality are superb—it has been used on Everest expeditions and been proven over decades of alpine use. Despite the toughness, the tent weighs just 5 pounds 1 ounce, which is just about as low as you’ll get for a serious mountaineering tent.
Keep in mind that the Black Diamond Eldorado is comfy for one person and gear, but not roomy for two. If you want extra space, a vestibule is available as an add-on for $170 (we’ve always been fans of a small vestibule built into the tent and don’t like the extra cost). Moreover, internal tent poles are considered by many to be a hassle—they can be difficult to set up and can poke holes through the corners of the tent if you aren't careful. Finally, single-wall tents don’t breathe nearly as well as double-wall models. But the weight savings is worth the sacrifices for many alpinists, making the Eldorado the top minimalist 4-season tent on the market.
See the Black Diamond Eldorado
Best All-Season Tent for Treeline Adventures
Packaged weight: 4 lbs. 1 oz.
Floor area: 29 sq. ft.
What we like: Ultralight for a double-wall tent yet decently strong.
What we don’t: Not prepared for full-on winter weather.
Many 4-season tents are overkill for mild winter conditions, and in those cases a decently strong (but slightly less bombproof) tent will do. Enter the “treeline” category, and our top pick MSR Access 2. The double-wall Access provides more protection than a 3-season model (with less mesh and a sturdier pole structure), but its 4-pound 1-ounce build is significantly lighter than most comparable options here. And unlike tents in our mountaineering category, the Access still has the convenience of two doors and two vestibules and 29 square feet of floor area (our testers jumped up to the three-person version for extra space plus a canine). All told, it’s a great middle-ground tent for winter and shoulder season trips with mild conditions or when you won’t be fully exposed.
The MSR Access’s “treeline” designation is a bit tricky. The last thing you want is to be in over your head in a winter storm, and the 4-pound weight is awfully light (meaning less wind and rain/snow protection overall). But we took the Access out in the snowy B.C. backcountry and even the Cordillera Huayhuash in Peru with no issues. It’s worth noting that in blustery conditions, the fly doesn’t fully extend to the ground and therefore you must create a snow wall for protection from drafts and drifts. And the tent doesn’t include MSR Blizzard stakes (just regular pegs), so we recommend bringing those along... Read in-depth review
See the MSR Access 2
Best Ultralight 4-Season Shelter
Packaged weight: 2 lbs. 13 oz.
Floor area: 50.7 sq. ft.
What we like: Incredible versatility for snow camping; lightweight and inexpensive.
What we don’t: Unstable in heavy winds, allows drafts in.
You’ll likely want a fully featured tent for sleeping in the snow, but as a dining shelter, gear storage, or simply a change of scenery when cabin fever sets in, the Black Diamond Mega Light is a total basecamp luxury. And we use the word “luxury” lightly—at 2 pounds 13 ounces all-in, it’s by far the lightest tent on our list. The most significant feature of the Mega Light is the floorless design, which allows you to dig out the snow underneath and create a seating or standing area for four. And in a pinch, the Mega Light can double as a lightweight sleeping shelter—at 50.7 square feet, you get about 20 more square feet of floor space than most options on this list.
But calling the Mega Light a 4-season tent is a bit of a stretch. Although it’s withstood winds up to 50 miles per hour throughout our testing, it just doesn’t compare to burlier tents like the Hilleberg Nammatj 2 GT below or even the single-walled Black Diamond Eldorado. In essence, it is a glorified tarp with no floor: in truly cold or windy conditions, it’s prone to flapping around and will feel quite drafty. It’s true that Black Diamond does make a bug net with a bathtub floor that can be paired with the Mega Light, but this will add an extra 3 pounds 11 ounces to your pack. But used correctly, the Mega Light is an impressively versatile design that is equally useful for winter-time camping as it is on a summer backpacking adventure... Read in-depth review
See the Black Diamond Mega Light
Best of the Rest
Packaged weight: 9 lbs. 15 oz.
Floor area: 32.3 sq. ft.
What we like: Good value for a burly basecamp-style design.
What we don’t: Heavier and less spacious than the Trango 2 above.
The North Face’s Mountain 25 has been trusted for years in the most inhospitable regions of the planet. And although it’s the heaviest tent on our list, you’ll be thankful for all 9 pounds 15 ounces when you’re weathering out tough conditions in basecamp. Similar to the Trango 2 above, the Mountain 25 features a burly double-wall build, stout poles, and time-tested fabrics that thrive in tough conditions. Two doors and vestibules provide multiple entry points and ample storage space. And the tent ventilates well, feels roomy with a peak height of 41 inches (3 inches taller than the Trango 2), is loaded with internal pockets, and is easy to set up and take down.
It was a tough call between the Trango 2 and the Mountain 25 for our top pick, but in the end the Mountain Hardwear won out for its roomier floorplan in a slightly lighter build. But the two tents go head to head in practically all other categories, including weather protection, durability, and price. And a footprint is now included with the Mountain 25 (the Trango’s is purchased separately for $80), but it’s unlikely you’ll need the extra durability for camping on snow. For a larger three-person version of this tent with more interior space, try The North Face VE 25... Read in-depth review
See the North Face Mountain 25
Packaged weight: 7 lbs. 4 oz.
Floor area: 31.2 sq. ft.
What we like: Premium build quality at a reasonable weight.
What we don’t: Extremely expensive and not a true mountaineering tent.
We’ll get the elephant out of the room first: Hilleberg tents are expensive. The Swedish company uses ultra-premium materials and focuses on small details like no other brand, and unfortunately you won’t find many bargains. But that doesn’t mean a Hilleberg isn’t worth it—at 7 pounds 4 ounces and with two doors and vestibules, the Allak is a full-service all-season tent that is considerably lighter than competing models like the Trango 2 above. The traditional dome shape isn’t built to stand up to the fiercest winds or heaviest snow loads, but it sure does a good job at trying.
The Allak walks the line between our “treeline” and “basecamp” categories, and Hilleberg’s Red Label (one step below the legendary Black Label) alludes to a similar classification. In other words, it’s a step up from the Access, but not quite on par with the Trango or Mountain 25 above. That said, in our experience, the Allak is strong enough to handle the gusty winds and heavy precipitation of true winter weather. For the ultimate in protection from Hilleberg, try the Staika, an even more buttoned-down 4-season tent with a similar dome design. The biggest compromise is weight as the Staika comes in at 8 pounds 13 ounces, and it costs $55 more as well... Read in-depth review
See the Hilleberg Allak 2
Packaged weight: 7 lbs. 8 oz.
Floor area: 36.3 sq. ft.
What we like: External pole structure sets up fast and reduces weight.
What we don’t: Unproven long-term performance.
Taking direct aim at the popular Trango 2 and Mountain 25 tents above is the Nemo Chogori 2. The big news with this tent is its double-wall construction and external pole structure, which makes it faster and easier to pitch in inclement weather than its main competition (the Trango and Mountain require you to set up the tent body and rainfly separately). Nemo doesn’t skimp on quality either with strong DAC poles and silicone-treated nylon on the fly for added durability and weatherproofing. And at 7 pounds 8 ounces, the Chogori is among the lighter basecamp-ready tents on this list.
What are the downsides of the Nemo Chogori? With 36.3 square feet of interior space, it’s roomy but its 39-inch peak height means less head room than most tents here. Further, at $750, it’s more expensive than the Mountain 25 ($689) and doesn’t come with the Trango’s long track record in extreme conditions. But we think the Chogori’s simple and quick set-up process, strong pole structure, and reasonable weight makes it a versatile option for mountaineering and other winter backcountry adventures.
See the Nemo Chogori 2
Packaged weight: 3 lbs. 3 oz.
Floor area: 24 sq. ft.
What we like: The lightest tent here but still waterproof; easy setup.
What we don’t: No mesh door and very limited floor area.
Black Diamond’s Eldorado above offers a great combination of bombproof weather protection in a streamlined build, but for some climbers it’s still too much tent. Enter the MSR Advance Pro 2, which features a packed weight of 3 pounds 3 ounces (almost a full 2 lbs. less than the Eldorado) and a tiny 24-square-foot floor area that fits on the smallest mountain ledges. Set up doesn’t get much easier (MSR even has a video of setting up the Advance Pro while perched on a bucket) and the external pole sleeves mean you don’t have to crawl in and out to get a perfect pitch. Side vents help with airflow, and a waterproof coating on both the body and floor keeps most moisture out (we recommend sealing the seams too).
The Black Diamond Firstlight below used to be our go-to tent for fast-and-light pursuits, but after too many nights of dealing with wet walls and pesky drips, we turned to the Advance Pro 2 as a more waterproof option (it doesn’t hurt that it’s slightly lighter too). But there are some compromises with the design, namely in terms of interior space. With a 24-square-foot floor, you lose 6 inches off the width of the Firstlight, making the Advance Pro 2 barely tenable for two. As a result, we recommend the MSR strictly for the most weight-conscious of missions and stick with a model like the Eldorado otherwise. And it’s important to note that the Advance Pro 2 does lack a mesh door, which might be a deal breaker for some.
See the MSR Advance Pro 2
Packaged weight: 4 lbs. 5 oz.
Floor area: 26 sq. ft.
What we like: Light for a double-wall tent and a good value.
What we don’t: Thin fabrics, small vestibule, and limited pockets.
The Nemo Kunai is an interesting and rather underappreciated 4-season tent. Most importantly, it’s one of lightest double-wall tents on this list at just 4 pounds 5 ounces—only the MSR Access is less, and that’s categorized as a treeline tent. But the Kunai is tough from head to toe, including a third pole over the front doorway to increase stability and four tie-downs threaded through the rainfly. In high winds, this secures the entire structure of the tent rather than just the fly (we’re looking at you, MSR Access).
Held up against other tents in our mountaineering category, the Kunai is competitive both in weight and protection. However, it stands out in its double-wall design, which offers greater breathability and comfort but has its downsides for an assault-style tent. For one, the Kunai’s 15-denier fly fabric is significantly thinner than that of single-wall tents (the Eldorado is made with 30D fabric), and we wouldn’t want to use it around abrasive rock. Second, a double-wall tent (especially with a vestibule) takes more time and space to set up—the Kunai wouldn’t be our first choice for bivying on a small ledge halfway up Fitz Roy, for example. But for light-and-fast winter camping and ski mountaineering, the Kunai offers an impressive combination of weather protection in a lightweight build.
See the Nemo Kunai 2P
Packaged weight: 4 lbs. 15 oz.
Floor area: 27.3 sq. ft.
What we like: Included vestibule makes it a good value.
What we don’t: Not a top choice for waiting out a rainstorm.
If you haven’t heard of The North Face’s new Futurelight fabric, you’re probably living in cave. TNF touts it as their most advanced waterproof/breathable technology yet, which is great news for a single-wall tent like the popular Assault (one of the biggest downsides of single-wall tents is condensation build-up). Aside from the boost in breathability, TNF’s mountaineering go-to retains its same beloved design, with a strong structure built to withstand serious winter conditions and multiple vents along the top to promote airflow. Notably, it manages to do all of this at a competitively low weight of 4 pounds 15 ounces (including a vestibule), making the Assault 2 Futurelight one of the most capable 4-season options for summit pushes.
Despite all of the hype, TNF’s Futurelight fabric still falls short of competing models. Both the Black Diamond Eldorado and MSR Advance Pro 2 above offer better wet-weather protection, and it doesn’t hurt that the Advance Pro 2 clocks in almost 2 pounds lighter. That said, the zip-off vestibule is a noteworthy strong suit of the Assault 2 (the Eldorado’s tacks on another $170 and 1 lb. 6 oz.) and is great for making the most out of the limited interior space. In the end, if you’re willing to take a minor hit in terms of weather protection (which might make sense in snowy weather or when the forecast looks clear), the Assault 2 is a suitable alternative to the Eldorado and will save you both money and weight.
See the North Face Assault 2 Futurelight
Packaged weight: 8 lbs. 3 oz.
Floor area: 30.1 sq. ft.
What we like: Super roomy vestibule and superb in high winds.
What we don’t: Tunnel design isn’t as adept at handling heavy snow loads as a dome tent.
The Allak is our favorite crossover treeline/basecamp tent from Hilleberg, and the Jannu is a premier lightweight option for mountaineering. But don’t overlook the Nammatj GT, which has a tunnel-shaped design that is built to withstand the toughest of conditions. This is one of Hilleberg’s legendary Black Label tents, which means that it’s among the strongest the company makes. With an all-in weight of 8 pounds 3 ounces, you will be hard-pressed to find a 4-season tent that does more while weighing less. The GT version of the Nammatj gets you an extended vestibule (a whopping 25.8 square feet of storage), which is extremely roomy and great for basecamping in particularly inclement conditions.
In terms of design, the tunnel shape of the Nammatj excels in high winds but isn’t quite as good at handling heavy snow loads as a dome-style tent. You’ll see a lot of photos of the Nammatj in pretty serious snow, but it is worth taking the time to dig yourself in and create a perimeter. And realistically, the toughness of the Nammatj GT is perfect for the high mountains and polar regions, but the tent can be overkill for mild-weather trips. For a similar tunnel design from Hilleberg for less extreme conditions at a lower weight, we love the Nallo, a Red Label tent that also comes in a GT version.
See the Hilleberg Nammatj 2 GT
Packaged weight: 3 lbs. 6 oz.
Floor area: 27.3 sq. ft.
What we like: Lightweight and super easy to pack.
What we don’t: Not waterproof.
The Black Diamond Firstlight is a polarizing 4-season tent. Some climbers rave about just how light and packable it is, while others decry its middling weather protection. What’s our take? It’s ideal for the right objective, and a poor choice for just about everything else. Under clear skies or in sub-freezing temperatures, the Firstlight provides a stable shelter at a very low packed weight (only the MSR Advance Pro 2 is lighter), and with better breathability than much of the single-walled competition (the mesh door is a big plus). Top it off with a super affordable price tag and a 6-inch wider floor area than the aforementioned MSR, and there’s a reason why climbers turn to the Firstlight year after year for minimalist protection from the elements.
The biggest shortcoming of the Black Diamond Firstlight—and we won’t sugar coat it here—is that it’s not waterproof. The NanoShield canopy fabric has a silicone coating that is water resistant, and you’ll have to seam seal the tent before using it to prevent leaks. In dry snow and wind, the tent puts up a valiant defense, but you’re guaranteed a wet night in anything more than a light rain. For comparison’s sake, even the minimalist MSR Advance Pro 2 above offers a significant bump in wet-weather protection. For fast-and-light mountain missions with a reliable forecast, the Firstlight can be a great choice, but the waterproofing and added protection of models like the MSR Advance Pro and BD Eldorado make them better companions for most 4-season conditions.
See the Black Diamond Firstlight
Packaged weight: 6 lbs. 5 oz.
Floor area: 32.9 sq. ft.
What we like: A great value for a 4-season tent.
What we don’t: Not built for the toughest of conditions.
Similar to the MSR Access above, there’s a time and place for the Arete. REI calls it “all season light,” which translates to a tent that offers better weather protection than a traditional 3-season model but isn’t built for super-strong winds or heavy snow loads. But with an updated four-pole design, the Arete is now more stable, and with additional head room too. At 6 pounds 5 ounces and only $399, it’s an economical way to hit the backcountry on a ski or snowshoe trip in mild to moderate conditions. Put simply, you won’t find a better deal anywhere on this list.
One thing in particular that we like about the REI Co-op Arete is that it’s a true year-round option. The double-wall design and substantial mesh door and vents means that it can be used for normal backpacking trips not involving the cold, but the Arete can hold its own on snow as well. As long as you don’t depend on the Arete to be your companion on high-altitude or particularly stormy missions, it’s great for the shoulder seasons and a healthy range of mild winter trips.
See the REI Co-op Arete ASL 2
Packaged weight: 10 lbs. 3 oz.
Floor area: 37 sq. ft.
What we like: Weather-ready expedition tent with the option of a roomier 3-person model.
What we don’t: Lacks the street cred of tents like the Trango 2 and Mountain 25 above.
Marmot is no stranger in the tent world. Their backpacking-focused Tungsten is a consistent best seller, but the Thor represents a move away from the fast-and-light focus into an expedition-ready design. With a double-wall build, large floor area, and hefty packed weight, the Thor falls into the same camp as tents like the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 and The North Face Mountain 25 above. It’s slightly heavier (although the extra 4-9 ounces is just a drop in the bucket), but with 37 square feet of floor area and 44 inches of head room (that’s 6 in. taller than the Trango) you get ample room to spread out and wait for the storm to pass.
With a robust 6-pole design, double walls, and fully taped seams, an expedition tent like the Marmot Thor is a reliable fortress against wind and rain. Unlike the single-wall options included here, you’re not going to be dealing with drips or sunken tent walls. And in terms of durability, it keeps step with the Trango 2 and Mountain 25 with a 40-denier canopy, 50-denier fly, and 70-denier floor. To be sure, the Mountain Hardwear and TNF tents have braved many more nights of winter weather and have the street cred to back it up, but the Thor is a dark horse and doesn’t fall too far behind. Finally, it’s nice to have the option of a larger size too: for only $50 and less than a pound more, the Thor 3 offers 10 extra square feet of floor area and even more headroom.
See the Marmot Thor
Packaged weight: 5 lbs. 14 oz.
Floor area: 26.3 sq. ft.
What we like: Strong and great ventilation for a single-wall tent.
What we don’t: Can feel a bit cramped and drafty.
For a tougher 4-season option from popular tentmaker Nemo, try the Tenshi. This single-wall tent is reminiscent of the Black Diamond Eldorado above, with a streamlined design for the high mountains. More so than the Eldorado, the Tenshi has mid-wall tie downs on each side that help prevent the tent from caving during strong winds. We also like the unique Condensation Curtain, a flap that comes down over the chest area and essentially quarantines moisture from breathing to one area of the tent. And unlike some single-wall tents, the vestibule and everything else you need with the Tenshi is included.
As with all lightweight mountaineering models, the Tenshi has some shortcomings. It’s relatively small with only 26.3 square feet of floor space, and we’ve found that the door can feel somewhat constricting. Further, it can be bulky to carry and takes up a healthy amount of room in your pack. Finally, ventilation is a strongpoint of this tent with multiple venting options, but it actually can become a bit drafty and cold if you’re sleeping solo.
See the Nemo Tenshi 2P
Packaged weight: 6 lbs. 3 oz.
Floor area: 41 sq. ft.
What we like: Very spacious but still lightweight.
What we don’t: Not as bombproof as heavier options.
With the Copper Spur HV3 Expedition, Big Agnes took their wildly popular backpacking tent and added a host of 4-season features to make an intriguing winter camping and mountaineering design. We’ve include the three-person model here, which is far roomier than any of the two-person options on our list, yet has a packaged weight of just over 6 pounds. Compared to the MSR Access 3 above, the Copper Spur weighs a little over a pound more but easily surpasses it in livability with more open, near-vertical walls. Further, the Big Agnes’s beefy, large-diameter poles, glove-compatible zipper pulls, and multiple tie-down options that are large enough to be staked out with skis make the Copper Spur Expedition a proper, winter-ready structure.
Despite its great space-to-weight ratio, the Copper Spur Expedition strikes us as an in-between design that doesn’t excel at anything. With thin fabrics and a hubbed, three-pole structure, it just can’t match the protection provided by the Trango 2 above, which boasts a four-pole build and burly (albeit heavy) 40D nylon walls. And true ounce counters will probably sacrifice a bit of comfort for the weight savings of a single-walled tent. But if you’re looking for a middle ground that prioritizes both space and weight, the Big Agnes is an intriguing alternative. For a more traditional basecamp-style design from Big Agnes for mountaineering or serious winter objectives, check out their Battle Mountain line.
See the Big Agnes Copper Spur HV3 Expedition
Packaged weight: 7 lbs. 15 oz.
Floor area: 34.5 sq. ft.
What we like: A great value and roomy.
What we don’t: Heavy, bulky, and limited performance capabilities.
We’ll start by saying that we’ve had positive experiences overall with Alps products, although they are budget in nature and definitely not among our top performers. But you can’t argue with the value, which is why the Alps Tasmanian made this list. At only $300, you get a fairly protective tent that will do the trick for most casual winter campers. We particularly like the roominess of this tent, which at 34.5 square feet is one of the biggest two-person models. Plus, the large mesh vent at the top does a fairly good job at promoting airflow and preventing condensation from building up.
It’s important to have reasonable expectations for a 4-season tent in this price range. First, the Alps Tasmanian is heavy at 7 pounds 15 ounces, not to mention it’s bulky and somewhat difficult to stuff into the included sack (although you’ll likely end up separating the tent body and poles to make it easier to fit in a pack). Second, we don’t recommend putting this tent to the limit in terms of tough winter weather. It should perform fine in the cold and light to moderate wind, but the tents above use higher-quality materials and much more complex designs. Finally, durability always is a concern with products that undercut the rest of the market in price. Alps does cover manufacturing defects under their warranty but not anything related to normal wear and tear.
See the Alps Mountaineering Tasmanian 2
|Mountain Hardwear Trango 2||$700||Basecamp||9 lb. 10 oz.||40 sq. ft.||38 in.||Double|
|Black Diamond Eldorado||$730||Mountaineering||5 lb. 1 oz.||30.8 sq. ft.||43 in.||Single|
|MSR Access 2||$600||Treeline||4 lbs. 1 oz.||29 sq. ft.||42 in.||Double|
|Black Diamond Mega Light||$320||Basecamp/treeline||2 lb. 13 oz.||50.7 sq. ft.||57 in.||Single|
|The North Face Mountain 25||$689||Basecamp||9 lb. 15 oz.||32.3 sq. ft.||41 in.||Double|
|Hilleberg Allak||$1070||Treeline/basecamp||7 lb. 4 oz.||31.2 sq. ft.||41 in.||Double|
|Nemo Chogori 2||$750||Basecamp||7 lb. 8 oz.||36.3 sq. ft.||39 in.||Double|
|MSR Advance Pro 2||$550||Mountaineering||3 lb. 3 oz.||24 sq. ft.||44 in.||Single|
|Nemo Kunai 2P||$500||Treeline/mountaineering||4 lb. 5 oz.||26 sq. ft.||42 in.||Double|
|TNF Assault 2 Futurelight||$659||Mountaineering||4 lb. 15 oz.||27.3 sq. ft.||42 in.||Single|
|Hilleberg Nammatj 2 GT||$1050||Basecamp||8 lb. 3 oz.||30.1 sq. ft.||37 in.||Double|
|Black Diamond Firstlight||$370||Mountaineering||3 lb. 6 oz.||27.3 sq. ft.||42 in.||Single|
|REI Co-op Arete ASL 2||$399||Treeline||6 lb. 5 oz.||32.9 sq. ft.||43 in.||Double|
|Marmot Thor||$699||Basecamp||10 lb. 3 oz.||37 sq ft.||44 in.||Double|
|Nemo Tenshi||$700||Mountaineering||5 lb. 14 oz.||26.3 sq. ft.||43 in.||Single|
|Big Agnes Copper Spur HV3||$550||Treeline/basecamp||6 lb. 3 oz.||41 sq. ft.||41 in.||Double|
|Alps Tasmanian 2||$350||Treeline||7 lb. 15 oz.||34.5 sq. ft.||46 in.||Double|
- 4-Season Tent Types
- Weight and Packed Size
- Double-Wall vs. Single-Wall Tents
- Size: Floor Area and Peak Height
- Ventilation and Condensation
- Silnylon vs. Polyurethane
- Storage: Vestibules and Interior Pockets
- Tent Pole Quality
- Stakes and Snow Anchors
- When Waterproofing Matters
- 4-Season vs. 3-Season Tents
- A Note on 4-Season Shelters
The term 4-season tent is a catch-all for any shelter that is made to withstand inclement, winter weather. However, there’s still a fair amount of variation within the category, which includes bulletproof, spacious, and heavy tents (great for basecamping), lightweight single-wall builds (great for alpine pushes), and everything in between. Below, we break down our three main categories of 4-season tents: mountaineering, basecamp, and treeline.
Mountaineering tents are built for high-alpine environments with weight as a primary consideration. Many of these tents are of the single-wall variety (more on that below) and make few compromises in terms of wind and weather protection. Square footage tends to be lower than basecamping and treeline tents, and the same goes for peak height. Almost all mountaineering tents are waterproof (or easily seam-sealed), with one exception being the lightweight Black Diamond Firstlight.
4-season tents of the basecamping variety are more comfortable and heavier than their mountaineering siblings above. To start, you may not have to carry your tent as far or as high, and therefore you can get away with packing more weight (and getting more tent in return). In addition, it’s highly likely that you’ll end up spending more time in a basecamp-style tent. Mountaineering tents are designed for fast and light adventures and summit pushes, but basecamping can be done in a variety of circumstances and conditions. Many of these tents have a double-wall design, which helps with ventilation, condensation prevention, and space, all at the expense of weight.
Treeline tents are the most trimmed-down 4-season models on the market. As the name implies, tents like the MSR Access 2 are designed for winter camping but not necessarily for heavy exposure in the high mountains. Compared to a 3-season version, a treeline tent will have a more substantial bathtub floor, less mesh, and heavier canopy and rainfly fabrics. But these tents fall short of basecamp and mountaineering models in terms of their toughness and durability, and it’s best not to put them to the test. They are, however, a nice option for light winter adventuring and serious 3-season backpacking in unpredictable weather.
4-season tents weigh more than their 3-season counterparts due to heavier and more durable fabrics, stronger poles, and beefier zippers. On the light end of the spectrum, the minimalist Black Diamond Firstlight has a feathery packaged weight of just 3 pounds 6 ounces, while a heavy-duty model like the Mountain 25 is nearly 10 pounds. Even if you look at the trail weight instead of the packaged weight (which doesn’t factor in stuff sacks, stakes, and guylines), you’ll still be close to 9 pounds for a number of tents on this list for the two-person version (the three- and four-person models weigh even more).
As with almost all types of outdoor gear, going up in weight has its advantages. Heavier 4-season tents generally are tougher and more weather resistant, ventilate better, and have more features. You’re getting a whole lot more tent, which may end up being worthwhile. We’ve been tent-bound in a Firstlight for three days on end, and even in with the rose-colored tint of nostalgia, the experience still remains a dismal one. We surely would have traded a few pounds of peanut M&Ms for the comfort and weather protection of a heavier tent like the TNF Mountain 25.
Weight and packed size generally go hand in hand and there is a strong correlation between the two variables. In many cases, two or more climbing partners can split up the components on the tent to less the burden for each. It’s worth noting that this process can be more difficult for single-wall tents than the double-wall variety—with no rainfly, the tent body is the vast majority of the weight and bulk. But with most double-wall tents, the canopy and rainfly often can be split up fairly evenly.
A critical distinction among 4-season tents is between double and single-wall designs. Simply put, a double-wall tent is composed of two separate layers: the inner tent canopy and an outer rainfly. Single-wall tents, on the other hand, have one layer of fabric to protect you from the outside elements. Single-wall tents are considerably lighter than double-wall models and still can be tough as nails, but at the cost of comfort, weather protection, and ventilation.
Which type of 4-season tent design should you choose? Unless weight and packed size are your top priorities, a double-wall wins out in basically every respect. By and large, you get more space, two doors rather than one, and larger vestibules (many single-wall tents forgo the vestibule completely). Second, with two layers of fabric between you and the elements, you get more robust and reliable weather protection. And most significantly, double-wall tents are far and away the more breathable option, as air can flow freely between the tent body and waterproof layer. Single-wall tents, on the other hand, are more minimalist in nature and meant for weekend summit assaults on Mount Rainer or the final push to the top of a Himalayan giant, while double-wall tents are more comfortable at a 17,000-foot camp on Denali in heavy wind and snow. If your trip or expedition is longer than a couple of days, a double-walled tent likely is your best bet.
The interior space of a tent is most commonly measured by the floor area, which we’ve provided in square feet in our product specs and comparison table. Compared to normal backpacking tents, 4-season tents range from minimalist to roomy, depending on their intended use. For example, a mountaineering tent like the MSR Advance Pro 2 is just 24 square feet, while the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 measures 40 square feet. Two climbers crammed into the Advance Pro 2 will be cramped like sardines whereas the Trango has a lot more room to sprawl. The moral of the story: if you’re looking for space, tents of the basecamp and treeline variety win out.
But square footage doesn’t tell the entire story as it only represents the floor: you also have the peak height and slope of the walls. A high peak height makes it easy to sit up and move around the tent, while heavily sloped walls have a tendency to make everything feel much smaller. We’ve provided the peak heights in our comparison table above, and the slope of the wall is best gauged by carefully studying the shape of the tent (or better yet, getting inside and seeing for yourself). Many tents now feature a cross-bracing pole on the ceiling, which provides lateral stability against wind and snow loads while also offering more headroom (think of a cube as opposed to a pyramid). More headroom can make those tent-bound days more bearable.
Last but not least: make sure to find a tent that is a few inches longer than you are. Otherwise, you will have to sleep at an angle or in the fetal position, neither of which is optimal. Most 4-season tents can accommodate people over 6-feet tall, but Hilleberg seems to be the favorite brand for those who tower over the rest.
By nature, 4-season tents are warmer than 3-season tents—they have less mesh, are designed to protect you from the elements, and therefore hold in more heat. Yet it’s important to keep fresh air flowing both to stay dry and to save you from the funk of your climbing partner’s socks. Over time, your breath will condense on the inner walls of the tent. In warmer weather, it will turn into beads of water on the ceiling and walls. In colder weather, it will turn to frost feathers. Both can fall on your face while you sleep and get your sleeping bag and other gear wet. And sleeping in a fully enclosed tent can make you feel groggy as you continually breathe stale air.
Proper ventilation will help to alleviate many of these issues. It’s important to remember that even the best 4-season tents are prone to some type of condensation, but some fare better than others. Double-wall designs tend to breathe better than single-wall tents, and the more vents the better. If drafts don’t make you uncomfortable, leaving doors and any available vents open can help mitigate condensation. In the product descriptions above we’ve tried to describe which tents in particular are strong or poor in terms of breathability, which certainly can be an important factor to your comfort.
When heavy winds and six feet of snow bury your tent at 14,000-foot camp on Denali, you want to know that it will be able to stand up to the load. Moreover, at higher altitudes and on glaciers, tents will be subjected to intense ultra-violet rays from the sun. This will wear your tent out faster than it would at lower altitudes or in more hospitable climates. For these reasons, many 4-season tents are made with heavy fabric (like 70D Nylon Taffeta with a quality coating) to stand up to the rigors of sunlight (which is stronger at higher altitudes due to the fact that there is less atmosphere to filter its rays), high winds, and driving snow and rain.
Time-tested tents such as the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2, The North Face’s Mountain 25, and numerous Hilleberg models are known for being able to stand up to years of abuse in the toughest climates known to man. They remain relatively light without skimping on durable materials. In general, as the cost of a tent goes down so does the build quality and durability. This isn’t a hard-and-fast rule by any means, but cheaper tents tend to be less durable and trustworthy than their more expensive counterparts.
Taking a quick dive into the nitty-gritty of fabric strength and waterproofing, there are two basic types of coatings used on 4-season tents: silicone (also referred to as silnylon) and polyurethane (commonly written as PU). Silicone-coated nylons are very expensive, typically weigh less, pack down smaller, and in the case of Hilleberg’s siliconized Kerlon fabrics, have incredible tear strength and longevity. But even Hilleberg uses polyurethane for the floor of their tents. Polyurethane can be laid on thicker than silicone for excellent puncture and abrasion resistance, is much easier to seam tape, and far less slippery than silicone, which is helpful on a tent floor to keep you from sliding around. The main downside is a shorter lifespan, particularly with low quality polyurethane that is prone to delaminating. But the benefits often don’t outweigh the added cost of silicone, so most non-Hilleberg tents have polyurethane coated rainflies and floors.
On an extended trip where inclement weather is likely, having ample space to store and dry your gear is an absolute necessity. Tents like the Mountain Hardwear Trango 2 and the Big Agnes Copper Spur Expedition are lined with pockets upon pockets. And yet it never ceases to amaze us how easily we fill those pockets with food, gear, and electronics once our packs are emptied. This storage is especially important considering that keeping your gear organized and separate from your partner’s is essential on any long trip (you wouldn’t want him or her to start eating your snacks!). Most tents also feature small loops meant to string guy line across the ceiling, which is useful to dry wet gear after a long day in bad weather.
Perhaps nothing on a 4-season tent is more important to comfort than the vestibule. A tent’s vestibule acts as a separate room that separates the dry, snow and rain-free interior of the tent from the harsh outside elements. Nothing will aggravate your partner more than soaking their dry down sleeping bag with your wet Gore-Tex and snow-ridden boots. The vestibule is where you seal yourself off from the majority of the outside weather and prepare to enter the tent dry, just like you would take your muddy shoes off outside before walking on someone’s carpet. Many tents have a smaller rear vestibule that can hold a few backpacks, but isn’t optimal for cooking or using as the main door. And keep in mind that many mountaineering tents forgo vestibules to shave weight, so be sure to choose accordingly if it’s an important feature to you.
Everyone who has backpacked knows that the number of doors a tent has matters a lot. Nothing is more frustrating than having to crawl blindly over your partner at 2 a.m. to answer nature’s call, and they would probably say the same. In general, lightweight mountaineering tents are most likely to have one door—it’s an easy way to cut weight and keep the footprint of the tent small (and the hope is that you’re not spending a lot of time in the tent anyway). Basecamping and treeline tents are likely to have two doors, which allows each person to enter and exit as they please. And one final consideration in relation to doors: a second door often means a second vestibule, which greatly enhances the storage opportunities and comfort.
In terms of tent pole quality, 4-season tents will have stronger (and heavier) poles that can withstand big gusts of wind. In cold weather, tent fabric shrinks and plastics and metals get brittle. Snapping a tent pole in a storm easily could result in a shredded tent, but stout metal poles (Easton, DAC, etc.) with long connector joints will provide torsional strength. And beware of any tent pole with a plastic tip (the end part of the pole that connects into the grommet of the tent). One year on Denali, one of our gear testers saw over a dozen of the same poles shear off at the tip when a company switched from metal to plastic.
In environments with unpredictable weather, it’s imperative to make your tent bombproof against wind and storms. Once while returning to Camp Muir after summiting Mount Rainier, one of our testers watched a tent roll down the Cowlitz Glacier and fall into a crevasse (true story). He later found out that the team had “anchored” their tent down with basic 6-inch stakes meant to hold a standard tent backpacking in the dirt.
When using a 4-season tent in an alpine environment, it is not uncommon to use backcountry skis, ice axes, pickets, ski poles, bamboo wands, or anything else that can be securely buried and not bend or break under high loads. On big mountains like Denali, it’s advisable to dig down two feet or more and fill around your “stake” with very compact snow. If you don’t have long skis or poles at your disposal, you can make a “deadman” anchor with any spare pieces of gear lying around. Simply wrap a stick, rock, tent stake—even a stuff sack filled with snow—with a guyline and bury it deep into the snow. What’s most important here is that you cover the deadman with heavy, compact snow so it does not become unanchored.
You might be wondering why on earth we would recommend a non-waterproof tent like the Black Diamond Firstlight here. After all, isn’t the whole purpose of a tent—especially a 4-season tent—to keep you dry? Yes—and no. Here is our reasoning: In truly wintery conditions when temperatures stay well below freezing, the chance of snow melting and seeping through the walls of a tent like the Firstlight is slim to none (and if it does, the DWR coating puts up a fairly solid defense). If there ever was a time to skimp on waterproofing, deep winter is it. On the other hand, in warmer temperatures there’s a good chance you’ll be using your tent as more of a shelter from wind than rain (think summer in Patagonia). In this case, a windproof tent is all you need.
There are a couple clear benefits to forgoing waterproof material in a tent. First, waterproof fabrics and seam taping increase weight and price—at 3 pounds 6 ounces and reasonable $370, the Black Diamond Firstlight is an ultralight, affordable option. In addition, waterproofing generally detracts from breathability—especially in a single-walled tent—which means that the other waterproof models trap noticeably more condensation than the Firstlight. But these benefits come with some responsibility. Make sure you seal your tent’s seams as a first line of defense against wet precipitation (Gear Aid’s Grip Seam Sealer is a proven choice). Second, routinely give your tent a shake when it’s snowing so that there is no opportunity for the snow to warm and turn to water. And when you’re not sure of what the weather might do, leave your Firstlight at home and bring a truly waterproof structure.
Four-season tents are the “take anywhere, do anything” tent, and they are designed to withstand the harshest environments in the world. We’ve watched entire vacations go by from the inside of a 4-season tent as inches of snow and rain fall outside, staying dry and comfortable inside (albeit stir crazy and disappointed). Like the old adage says: “don’t bring a knife to a gunfight.” Likewise, don’t bring a tent designed for the Pacific Crest Trail to the stormy realms of the Cascade volcanoes, Denali, or Patagonia’s Torre Valley.
When you are using a 4-season tent, odds are you will be in a climate prone to inhospitable weather. 4-season tents are more robust, heavier, and more durable than standard backpacking tents, and designed to withstand heavy wind, rain and snow. They’re also packed with features, including flies that extend farther down the main body of the tent (and some models feature snow skirts—flaps that are meant to be buried in snow), high bathtubs on the main body to prevent rain and snow from leeching into the tent, and large vestibules that provide ample room for storage and cooking. It’s not uncommon on big mountain expeditions in Alaska to see intricate kitchens where teams have dug pits in the snow and can comfortably stand, cook, and socialize in the enclosed space of their vestibule.
Most of the tents above feature a pole-supported design that provides 360-degree security from wind, rain, snow, and bugs. But for those who value weight-savings above all else, a 4-season shelter offers weather protection almost on par with a treeline model at half the weight or less. To maximize their strength-to-weight ratios, popular 4-season shelters like the Black Diamond Mega Light above and Hyperlite Mountain Gear Ultamid 2 are floorless, non-freestanding, and utilize a center pole (often two attached trekking poles or ski poles) to create a taught, pyramid shape. When properly set up, these tents can hold strong in moderate wind and shed driving rain and snowfall.
Our favorite use for a 4-season shelter is as an additional living space while basecamping on snow. By digging out the base, you can create a sitting and standing area for four (or more!) that offers a great change of pace from tent life. Then, when you need a true respite from bugs, wet ground, or seeping rain, you always can escape to the security of your tent. The most intrepid of adventurers might opt for a 4-season shelter as their dedicated sleeping area, but we only recommend this for trips when the weather is mild or when weight really wins out: long ski traverses, fast-and-light climbs, and backcountry treks that cover a lot of distance and require a very light pack.
Back to Our Top 4-Season Tent Picks Back to Our 4-Season Tent Comparison Table